Pirates, culinary chaos, and a mysterious treasure—sometimes the oddest things spark the wildest adventures. This tale blends absurdity, vengeance, and a very unexpected ingredient, proving that even the most peculiar of prompts can lead to untold madness.
Today’s word prompt was mignonette, which can refer to a shallot-infused vinegar sauce commonly served with oysters, or in some contexts, a small garniture of herbs. What began as a simple culinary concept quickly spiraled into full-blown, high-seas absurdity. A blend of pirates, culinary obsession, and the unpredictable chaos of adventure—this tale proves that even the most refined of ingredients can spark the wildest of stories.
This piece takes inspiration from swashbuckling legends, culinary obsession, and the kind of reckless, rum-fueled storytelling that I hope would make Hunter S. Thompson proud.
With a dash of satire, a splash of vinegar, and a rogue’s dose of exaggeration, this is a story of obsession, revenge, and the fine art of flavor piracy.
And with that, please enjoy A Spoonful of Revenge
A Spoonful of Revenge
A Tale of Rum, Betrayal, and Shallot-Infused Madness
I was three sheets to the wind in a Black Gull Cove dive when the news hit—Captain Finn “Ironbelly” Graves had been robbed. The tavern reeked of salt and spilled grog, its wooden beams blackened by decades of pipe smoke. A crooked bartender sloshed out murky rum, thick as molasses, while sailors murmured over half-eaten bowls of questionable chowder. Not of gold, not of rum, but of his mignonette sauce.
This was no ordinary seafood dressing. No, this was Graves’ legendary stash, aged in barrels that once held contraband cognac, infused with secret herbs stolen from the King’s own kitchen. Oysters trembled at its touch. Even the most hardened seafaring dogs wept at the mere aroma. And now, it was gone.
Word spread fast. First mate Grady the Goat swore he saw a rival captain, Patrice “Saucy” LeClair, licking her fingers suspiciously. Patrice wasn’t just a thief; she was a connoisseur of flavors, a pirate who plundered delicacies instead of doubloons. Her ship, The Saucier’s Revenge, was notorious for raiding spice caravans and absconding with barrels of rare vinegars. The deckhands swore a Frenchman was involved. Graves was raving—eyes wild, cravat askew—shouting about “culinary treason of the highest order.”
By dawn, the ship was in chaos. Someone had left a single empty vinegar bottle at Graves’ cabin door, a clear message: You’ll never taste glory again, old man.
And so began the Mignonette Mutiny.
We set sail, fueled by vengeance and questionable sobriety, with Graves leading the charge, demanding “we spill blood or balsamic by sundown!” We chased Patrice across the high seas, through cannon fire, kraken-infested waters, and at least one ill-advised encounter with a particularly vengeful mermaid—who, it turns out, had been swindled out of a shipment of saffron by Patrice years ago. She cursed us with bad wind and worse luck, forcing us to row for miles until we found our way back on course.
When we finally caught up, it was a catastrophe of maritime absurdity—muskets fired, barrels rolled, and Graves tackled Patrice into a vat of stolen sauce. A brutal, slippery brawl ensued, the air thick with vinegar and fury. Patrice, laughing through bruised lips, swore she stole the sauce not out of spite, but to prove she could improve it.
In the end, Graves took back his beloved mignonette—but he was never the same. He spent his days obsessively tinkering with the recipe, chasing perfection like a man haunted. Some say he vanished, retreating to a remote island where he built a temple to the sauce. Others claim he died tasting a subpar batch, heartbroken.
All I know is this: if you ever see a pirate whispering to a bottle of shallot-infused vinegar at a dockside tavern… walk away.
(c) Eric Montgomery
Did you enjoy this story?
If you enjoyed A Spoonful of Revenge, I’d love for you to share it with others who might appreciate it.
As an independent author, I rely on word-of-mouth to help my work reach more readers. Your support means the world to me!
And… if you’re looking for more creative inspiration, tune in to my podcast “Prompted!” where we explore new writing prompts and ideas every week!
Subscribe and Listen Today!